Dutch Woman With Alzheimers Euthanized — Even After She Changed Her Mind

A doctor went through with euthanizing a patient even while the patient fought her, because the doctor didn't want the patient to get "cold feet."

By Nancy Flory Published on February 14, 2017

A 70-year-old Dutch woman sipped her coffee and excitedly made plans with her husband and children to spend the afternoon with them and eat a meal together. The woman suffered from Alzheimer’s disease, but was lucid enough to know her family and make plans for the day. What she didn’t know was that she would not be spending the afternoon with them or eating lunch — her family had already made plans with the doctor to end her life. 

The unidentified Alzheimer’s patient had suffered from the disease for four years and wrote a living will, saying she did not want to go into a nursing home and would prefer assisted suicide when she determined the “time was right,” reported the National Catholic Register. However, as of last year, her dementia had progressed to the point that her aging husband could not care for her. When she entered the nursing home she told the staff that she wished to die but “not right now.”

The day that she was euthanized she was making plans to spend time with her family. She didn’t know that her husband had decided with the doctor that “she was ready to die.” The sedative the family put in her coffee didn’t work, so the doctor came into the room to administer the first of three fatal drugs. She aroused from her sleepy state and fought the doctor who was attempting to give her the shot. It was then that the patient’s family was asked to hold her down for the procedure. According to a report from the Dutch Regional Review Committee, the doctor did not stop because she did not think that it was “appropriate to halt termination of life,” as the topic of assisted suicide had been discussed for a while and the doctor didn’t want the patient to “get cold feet.”

While the patient frequently talked with nursing home staff about wanting to die, when asked by the doctor if she wanted to die, she repeatedly replied, “Not now … it’s not so bad!”

However, the report states that the woman had “no clear advanced directive,” and had “never verbally requested euthanasia.” But it wouldn’t have mattered. According to the report, “Even if the patient had said, ‘I don’t want to die,’ the doctor would have continued the termination.”

The committee determined that the doctor had “not acted in accordance with the due care criteria” within the Termination of Life on Request and Assisted Suicide Act of 2002. The committee also found that the doctor “crossed a line” by administering the drug in the patient’s coffee without her knowledge and failing to suspend the euthanasia when the patient reacted negatively to the administration of the drugs. When euthanizing patients, said the committee, doctors must avoid coercion as well as the appearance of coercion at all costs. Even so, the doctor was not sanctioned. 

Alistair Thompson of Care Not Killing, a U.K. group opposing assisted suicides and euthanasia, said that once euthanasia is made lawful for terminally ill patients, it’s only a matter of time before it affects the weak and vulnerable. The law says “We care so little for people, that we allow it. ‘You’re old; your life must be over.’ ‘You’re disabled; your life must not be worth living.’ … This is another good example of why the law has to be clear: that we do not kill people who are ill or disabled.”

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • Autrey Windle

    I feel like going downtown and walking with the old man who wandered the streets when I was a little girl with his sign saying ‘REPENT! THE END IS NEAR”. It’s hard to pray for these monsters when the heathen I used to be wants me to wish them to hell…

  • Who’s to decide you’re too old to live? When I was a kid, I thought 25 was old. Remember, karma always comes back around.

    • Michael Gore

      maybe we can just go for something like Logan’s Run and kill everyone off at age 30… With the exception of course of an enlightened few to guide us witless sheep!

  • Dean Bruckner

    This “doctor” deserves to have done to him what the Nazis did to their medical experiment subjects, resulting in their deaths. He is a demonic monster.

  • Paul

    If you can abort babies because you can’t care for them then why not adults as well? See, you gotta look at this through the eyes of depraved moral relativists.

  • MAGA2017

    Pathetically sad her family- presumably her own spouse, among them, holding Mom down for multiple injections of a fatal cocktail. Actually horrific way to depart this life.

    We cheapen human life in the womb to mere “choice” even when a developing child is fully viable, sensing and feeling.

    How is it then “a stretch” humankind will soon exterminate “our loved ones” without consternation, nor any moral examination and absent consequence for abhorrent acts of inhumanity?

  • LYoung

    This is such a sad and horrible story. I’ve worked in an “assisted home” and watched many people die…when they were ready. I had 9 friends go in less than a year and each one died peacefully and were surrounded by loved ones. God has ordained a time for us to die and we need not “assist” Him.

  • Bill

    Very sad – My wife and I have been married nearly 50 years.
    She was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s about 4 years ago.
    I have taken care of her myself with some help.
    I must say that our love for each other has grown many times over.
    I’ve learned many things over these years, but the greatest of these is that love has many levels, and if you have never had to take care of a loved one; you have missed one of the highest levels. God Bless.

  • Liz Litts

    How long until the ‘assisted’ laws in this country become what this story is about?

Inspiration
How Do We Prepare to be Fully Prepared?
Dudley Hall
More from The Stream
Connect with Us