Confusing the Government With God

The Tower of Babel by Pieter Bruegel the Elder (1563)

By John Zmirak Published on April 9, 2018

This past weekend was a hope-filled one. I traveled to Virginia. There I met a wonderful group of high school and college students. Courtesy of Young America’s Foundation, these 80 or so young people gathered to hear from intellectuals and leaders. And also from me. The conservative group organized this Catholic-specific conference to arm young people with better arguments and point them to first principles. Those who spoke included a number who have appeared here at The Stream.

Stream executive editor Jay Richards unfolded four of the key myths that turn good people away from the free market. Scholar Paul Kengor told the students the deeply dramatic story of President Ronald Reagan and St. John Paul II. In his book, A Pope and a President, he delves in depth into the most remarkable partnership ever to dismantle an evil empire. Students for Life of America leader Kristan Hawkins urged the students to invite their friends into a movement to defend the most vulnerable Americans. To see the whole program go here, though my video hasn’t been posted yet.

A Dreamy Talk

And the poor kids had to listen to me as well. Not even me at my best, but me at 9:00 in the morning (8 am, Central time). What I’m usually doing at such an hour is neatly summed up as “REM sleep.” So I roused myself at this ungodly hour on a Saturday morning, with a lot of hotel coffee. The talk that resulted was a little more free-form than most of my articles, I think because part of my brain was really still dreaming.

The event was something of a dream-come-true. Here were all these bright and eager young people, chirping like hungry birds for something solid to feed their minds. And generous donors had equipped each one of them with a free copy of my Politically Incorrect Guide to Catholicism to take home. So even if I wasn’t all that coherent in my remarks, they’d have the book that connects the dots to read at their leisure.

Here’s the gist of what I told the students.

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

The Tower of Babel

One of the worst problems in history has been this: We mistake God for the government, and the government for God. By history I mean ancient, as in the Book of Genesis: What else should we call the Tower of Babel but this: A massive government program ordered by a tyrant. Its goal? To forge a purely human link to heaven. To assert that the state (and via group narcissism, its people) could grab eternal glory by man’s own sweaty exertions. God knew just what to do: He knocked down the tower and confused all its people by making them speak different languages.

Now, I’d once thought of this bible passage was in part a “just-so” story to explain the diversity of human tongues. But it’s much more than that. It’s a warning against attempts to weld human peoples together artificially. To ever form one world government, as some idealists dream. 

The dream of imposing a single currency, a secret oligarchy, and limitless alien migrants on more than dozen countries will end just as badly as Lenin’s experiment. I’m confident that in my lifetime, delighted crowds will smash the EU’s Brussels headquarters with pickaxes, as they did the Berlin Wall.

Pharaoh and Caesar Hunting God’s People

The next instance where people conflated God and their rulers was in Egypt. A Pharaoh whose people he taught to worship him as a kind of god enslaved and persecuted the genuine God’s people. He humbled Pharaoh, and set His people free.

The Soviet Union was one attempt to impose a single system on all the peoples of the world. It collapsed in a mass of rusted tanks and graffiti-covered walls. The European Union is another, and it seems every bit as doomed.

Next up was the turn of the Christians, who sought no political power inside the Roman empire. They weren’t even separatists. But the desperate rulers of a crumbling empire decided that the glue which would hold their system together would have to be religion: Every Roman resident would have to acclaim him as a god.

The Church said politely, “No.” A massive persecution that lasted on and off for centuries yielded thousands of martyrs. But the sight of people with enough faith to willingly die in the Colosseum had an unexpected effect: It shocked the jaded Romans, and made them think. What were they willing to die for? What in the mass of mystery religions and philosophical systems offered such blessed certainty? Were the Christians on to something? And so the faith kept on spreading, and with Constantine conquered the empire itself.

Treating Caesar Like Moses

That offered the next temptation to conflate divine and human authority. Christian emperors, for all the good they accomplished, were treated almost as idols. Though they had no religious role, they were treated as quasi-priestly, as a bridge between earth and heaven. And why not? They had the power of life and death over their subjects. The Church gave them the power to persecute heretics, and keep Christendom “pure.” In the East, this led to a church that was all-too-subject to secular interference.

In the West, the empire collapsed, and churchmen had to step up and help keep public order. That had its own dangers. Once bishops and monks were administering large parts of countries, that tempted the rulers to try to get them under their control. The good works the Church did made it a tempting target. One of the least-noticed effects of the Reformation? The almost complete take-over of the Church by the state. Yes, in the England of Henry VIII. But not just there.

The Reformation divided the Church and weakened its stance against the state. As the price of not imitating Henry, kings could demand outrageous influence over the Church’s every function. In Catholic France, the king named all the bishops. Likewise in Spain, where the king also prevented the documents of the Council of Trent from getting published for 70 years.

Liberty Reborn in Britain

Ironically, it was in England where the splintering of Christians into so many quarreling factions made something remarkable happen: People rediscovered the idea that the government shouldn’t try to manage its subjects’ religion. That led them to dust off medieval ideas of resistance to central tyranny, and helped found the tradition of liberty we now enjoy in America. In fact, when the U.S. was founded, the Holy See wrote to Congress asking permission to name a bishop. The U.S. Congress was puzzled. It wrote back, explaining that Catholics were free here to do as they pleased. In not one Catholic country in Europe was that really true.

It’s our duty as citizens and believers to make sure it stays true. There are many, and growing, threats to religious liberty in America. Each of them grows from the new religion that our elite classes have adopted and wish to impose. Unlike them, we know the difference between God and Caesar. And we won’t worship idols. Instead, we will fight.

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • John

    A pause every believer should make and evaluate the stands he takes, where his faith is placed, and just what he is fighting for. For the weapons of are warfare are not physical but spiritual. These will indeed pull down strongholds. Thanks John for the article.

  • Chip Crawford

    Catholic is a part, not the whole of the Church of Jesus Christ.
    And there is a qualifier in that a Catholic must be an actual born again Christian to be a part of the real Church.

    • Alfy

      Catholic, means universal. All baptized are “born again with water and spirit”. Let us not forget our Lutheran,Anglican,Eastern Orthodox,Oriental, etc who practice infant baptism. Let us especially not forget our Syrian brothers and sisters in Christ who are being killed for their beliefs. 2000 year old Syrian Christian communities under persecution. Jesus prayed, may they be one so all may believe!

      • Chip Crawford

        Let’s not forget God’s Word, which lives and abides forever.

        • Mark Cain

          Technically Neil Gorsuch is the first protestant on the Supreme Court since 2010. Raised Catholic, he attends a progressive Episcopalian church. All the other judges are Catholic or Jewish. Consequently, it is five judges raised Catholic who stand between us and disaster. Let’s pray their knowledge and respect of God’s word will guide them and their decisions.

    • Mara319

      Catholics are actually born again at their Baptism. Yeah, of water and the Spirit…by which we hope to enter the Kingdom of Heaven.

      For us Catholics, water and Spirit (baptism) is not mere symbolism but a Sacrament. It is sacrament of our participation in the Death and Resurrection of Jesus (Colossians 2:12).

      In baptism, we’re freed from the chains of Original Sin—the state of man since the Fall—and became adopted children of God (Romans 8:14-16). Our souls are marked with an indelible “character” (like a brand) indicating we belong to Christ. Jesus Christ owns us.

      In baptism, Catholics are also given the free gift called Grace of the theological virtues of Faith, Hope, and Love.

      In baptism, we are born again in water and Spirit by the authority given by Our Lord Jesus Christ to His ONE TRUE CHURCH.

      • Kathy

        I write from experience, both mine and others. It is common for people to just believe what they are taught and never question it, thinking it must be true. Why wouldn’t it be? It may or may not be accurate information you are receiving, and we must be discerning, especially when it comes to Scripture. I encourage everyone to research for themselves, not relying solely on the doctrine of their own particular church. After studying more of other Christian beliefs you find that what you have been taught makes sense in a biblical context, then fine. If not, you at least getting another perspective. It may just open your eyes as it did mine.

    • Chip Crawford

      You can make up all the little nuances, authoritative entitlements and ritualistic accoutrements you like, but if you desire entrance into God’s eternal Heaven upon departing this life, you’ll need to have consulted with him on HIS ways and qualifiers.

  • Alfy

    Thank you John. This is a great article that I will be sharing with others.

  • TrueConservative

    “Confusing the Government with God”
    –that’s the FOUNDATION of liberalism !!!!

  • Charles Burge

    I wonder how you infer that the Tower of Babel was “program ordered by a tyrant”? A plain reading of Genesis 11 seems to suggest it was more of a grass roots effort.

    • Zmirak

      I guess I was reading into the story my knowledge of the oldest human governments, which were all top-down divine monarchies.

      • Charles Burge

        In general I think that’s a pretty sound assumption. In Genesis 11, however, I think humanity was still mostly “fresh off the boat”, and the concept of government was still in its infancy.

        As for the main point of your article, I heartily agree that it’s a temptation that Christians and non-Christians alike fall into far too often. John Stonestreet, one of my favorite Christian thinkers (and a protegé of Chuck Colson), often laments that people seek political solutions to problems that are not inherently political in nature.

    • fiveHats

      Babel was created by Nimrod who is recorded as the first “mighty man” or hunter of men, an antichrist. Those are all tyrants.

  • Sapient

    To all the globalists…”But man, proud man, dress’d in a little brief authority, most ignorant of what he’s most assured. His glassy essence—like an angry ape—plays such fantastic tricks before high heaven as makes the angels weep; who, with our spleens, would all themselves laugh mortal.” WS…

  • Let’s remember who calls the shots. Religion is legal in the United States thanks to the Constitution, not the Bible.

    And on that topic, the First Amendment, with its definition of separation of church and state, is vital for the Christian as much as the atheist or Muslim.


    How, exactly, does tearing apart the institution that brought 80 years of peace and cooperation among Western European nations (after centuries of ongoing conflicts) in any way advance the cause of humanity? Where does the Bible say to “keep immigrants out and don’t welcome the stranger?” And yes, government should stay out of religion and not tell people who they can marry or when they can have sex based on the Bible. On that, I agree with the author.

Is Your Heart Heavy? God Knew It Would Be
Charles Spurgeon
More from The Stream
Connect with Us