Israel’s Looming Civil War

Israel's fragile democracy hangs in balance between traditional and progressive movements.

An ultra orthodox jewish man demonstrates in front of Israeli protesters in Jerusalem, Sunday, Nov. 20, 2016. Dozens of LGBT activists have protested in Jerusalem against comments reportedly made by the city's chief rabbi disparaging the gay community.

By Michael Brown Published on August 1, 2018

There is a civil war looming in Israel, but very few are talking about it.

I’m not referring to the potential of a civil war between Israelis and Palestinians. Nor am I referring to a war with bombs and guns and knives. I’m referring to an ideological war that has the potential of tearing the nation in half.

It is the war between ultra-Orthodox Jews and liberal Israelis. The rift is large and growing, and it was underscored by the conflict this week between LGBT activists and ultra-Orthodox rabbis.

But first, some important demographics.

A Case for Orthodoxy

Ultra-Orthodox Jews (called haredim) are the fastest growing segment in Israel. It currently makes up roughly 15 percent of the Jewish population (about 1 million out of 6 million). And based on current birth rates, the haredim could make up more than one-third of the total Jewish population of Israel by mid-century. (Ultra-Orthodox Jews have very high birth rates coupled with very little assimilation into the secular culture.)

As explained in 2016, “While haredim made up just 9.9% of the Israeli population in 2009, with 750,000 out of 7,552,100, by 2014 that figure had risen to 11.1%, with 910,500 haredim out of a total Israeli population of 8,183,400. [These figures refer to the total population of Israel, including Arabs.]

“By 2024, the study predicts, haredim will make up 14% of the Israeli population, rising to 19% by 2039, and 27% by 2059. At that point haredim will be a whopping 35% of the total Jewish population, outnumbering the secular, traditional, traditional-religious, and religious sectors.”

But there’s more to the story.

Israel is a very fragile democracy, by which I mean that it takes a coalition of various parties to lead the nation. It’s not as simple as electing President Trump or President Obama. Instead, Israelis vote for parties, which are led by individuals. Various parties then work together to get a total of 61 seats in the Knesset (Parliament).

The Coalition of Parties

In the last election (2015), Prime Minister Netanyahu’s party, Likud, got the most seats. But in total, Likud only won 30 seats, meaning that it had to work together with other parties to reach the magic number of 61. (Overall, 10 different parties won seats; there were a total of 25 parties that competed.)

To put his coalition together, Netanyahu had to include two ultra-Orthodox parties, United Torah Judaism and Shas, both of which won just 6 seats. But they are major power brokers in the government with disproportionate influence, since Likud could not govern without them.

Despite their small size, they can demand special benefits. These include government support so more of their men can devote themselves to day and night Torah study, along with exemption from serving in the military.

What makes this even more interesting is that many haredim are anti-Zionist. Their leaders opposed the modern state of Israel before 1948, feeling that: 1) it was up to the Messiah to regather the exiles and reestablish the nation; 2) a secular Jewish state would be an abomination in God’s sight; and 3) an Israel established by man rather than God would increase world anti-Semitism. To this day, most haredim do not celebrate Israel’s Independence Day; some actually mourn.

And remember: These are very traditional Jews, with no TV’s, limited internet access, and tightly controlled dress codes and sexual mores. Their religious traditionalism makes serious American Evangelicals look like worldly sinners.

The Liberal Left

Yet the rest of the Jewish Israeli population is quite “progressive” and liberal. As noted in Israel Today, “As a nation, Israel prides itself on tolerance toward and acceptance of homosexuals. There are openly-gay members of Knesset; the IDF touts its integration of the LGBT community; the Israel Ministry of Tourism advertises Tel Aviv as a top gay travel destination; and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu recently highlighted Israel’s homosexual credentials at the American Jewish Committee conference.”

And with LGBT activism getting bolder and louder, a conflict with ultra-Orthodox Jews becomes even more certain. This especially true in Jerusalem, since it boasts a significant haredi population and is considered particular holy in Jewish tradition.

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

Recently, however, to the consternation of liberal Israelis, “Netanyahu and his Likud Party … helped defeat a motion to include homosexuals in a new amendment to Israel’s surrogacy laws. The amendment enables single would-be mothers to now make use of surrogacy on the state’s dime. Homosexuals hoped to be included in the new regulations, and took to the streets of Tel Aviv in mass protest when the Knesset rejected their appeals.

“In response to the liberal outcry, Chief Rabbi of Jerusalem Aryeh Stern insisted that children born to gay couples would ‘enter a very strange and unnatural life,’ and that the government of Israel shouldn’t be party to such a ‘wretched’ state of affairs.”

Growing Tensions

Stern’s remarks were widely vilified, as a result of which 200 ultra-Orthodox rabbis wrote a letter supporting him, ending with, “The media’s brainwashing that seeks to destroy the concept of family and turn perverts into heroes will not succeed, and nor will the attempt to silence rabbis and sane people and turn them into delusional extremists.”

Not surprisingly, this letter received even more severe backlash. “A petition was started demanding that any of the 200 rabbis who draw a government salary should be fired immediately.”

At the same time, the city has scheduled a gay pride march for Jerusalem this Thursday, August 2. The chief rabbi of the city “has called for the city to remove rainbow flags from the vicinity of the city’s major Synagogues.”

This is quite understandable. But in recent years, things got totally out of hand, and “16-year-old Shira Banki was killed at Jerusalem Pride in July 2015, when [the] ultra-Orthodox Jewish man Yishai Schlissel went on a stabbing spree.”

Tensions, then, are very high.

And they could soon reach a boiling point as the secular population of Israel leans more and more to the left and the haredim more and more to the right. Each continues to grow in numbers and power.

For those who pray for the wellbeing of the nation, this is something to keep in prayer.

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • john appleseed

    According to Dr. Brown (whom I love), speaking of traditional Jews, “Their religious traditionalism makes serious American Evangelicals look like worldly sinners.”
    I disagree.
    Actually, their religious traditionalism makes themselves look like Pharisees, and they make serious Evangelicals look more like Jesus by comparison.
    Serious Evangelicals are balanced between the extremes of legalistic people on one end and liberals on the other.
    I wish Dr. Brown had used a phrase such as “church folks in the US,” rather than “serious American Evangelicals.”

    • john appleseed

      Dr. Brown is a prolific writer, and 99% of his stuff is excellent, gracious, and exactly what needs to be said.
      I just think he should have thought through that sentence more carefully.

      • Paul

        A case of hyperbole I think.

    • Jim Walker

      I read that comment more like tongue in cheek with a hint of sarcasm.

    • Irene Neuner

      I am part of a group of ‘serious Christians’ (including Catholics) who dumped cable tv 10 years ago, consume a severely restrict diet of all media, don’t use birth control, refuse to put our children in state schools and don’t buy them smartphones and iPads because we are certain that these things either stifle our relationship with God and his son Jesus or are in conflict with his heart.

      Dr. Brown’s reference to comparing ‘serious evangelicals’ with the ‘ultra orthodox’ views was useful and well received by myself.

      Furthermore it makes our hearts fail to hear of every nation and city that embraces homosexuality and abortion.

  • James Blazsik

    What is unmentioned says a lot. Members of the indigenous Christian communities that reside in Israel 1000’s of years before Israel became a nation in ’48. It is well known that the ultra-orthodox also persecute Christians.

    • Andrew Mason

      So do the Left though so does it really matter?

      • James Blazsik

        What’s your point? Are you saying that Christians in Israel don’t matter?

        • Andrew Mason

          Absolutely not! The article was about the conflict between Leftists and Ultra-Orthodox Jews. You added that Ultra-Orthodox Jews also persecute Christians. I merely balanced that with the note that Leftists also persecute Christians. If both sides persecute Christians then a victory by either side is unlikely to benefit Christians.

          Strictly speaking Israel was only wiped out about 1,900 years ago, though it had been a client state for centuries by then, and restored again about 70 years ago. There’s roughly a century overlap between the ancient state of Israel existing, albeit as a client state, and Christianity.

  • tz1

    (Sarcasm Dispensensationalism)

    The LGBTQ liberals will and should win so that Jesus will come back and rapture us while the Antichrist will slaughter all but 144k virgin male Jews.

    Revelation 11:8 Their bodies will lie in the public square of the great city–which is figuratively called Sodom and Egypt–where also their Lord was crucified.

    Hey, if the two witnesses are killed and have to lie in the public square in neo-Sodom, AKA Jerusalem, the faster we turn it into San Francisco’s Castro or Folsom streets and have bath-houses replace the Synagogue the better.

  • Dennis Chkolnik

    I prefer to stand with the religious and be persecuted for my faith, If it comes to it, than stand with evil doers, promoting what the Bible calls abominations, whoever the promoters are, passive or active: Netanyahu, Bennett, Liberman, Yesh Atid (Lapid). There are Very few today in Israel that are vocal about the “parades”and speak against them. And it’s very sad…..God Most High is waiting for us to raise up our voice and speak up for the Truth, Sanctity of marriage, Sanctity of life, and against the division of the Land….We MUST join those very few who do stand up, even if they are religious, ultrareligious, or any kind, for when our Messiah Yeshua returns, He is not gon’na ask us what did you believe, but what did you do with your belief(faith)? And there is a saying “If you don’t stand for something, you will fall any thing…” of course our war is not a war of physical violence, for our weapons are spiritual, BUT to stand we must, to protest against darkness we MUST!!!!

  • Up_Words

    Single women seeking to have children via surrogate means: Oy vey!

  • Theocracy is bad, OK?

    • Greg Paley

      You da man, Alan.

    • Patmos

      Didn’t even read the article, just got triggered like the selfish troll that you are.

    • Andrew Mason

      The theocracy of the Left, the theocracy of the Haredim, or both?

  • Patmos

    The selfish and perverted are just plain intent on destroying the hedge of protection currently keeping Syria and the like at bay.

  • Shlomo Vinishsky

    The real mystery is how LGBT multiply faster then haredim?

To God be the Glory
James Robison
More from The Stream
Connect with Us