Is Donald Trump Racist? Part I

Donald Trump speaking at the 2013 Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in National Harbor, Maryland.

By Harry Jackson Published on May 25, 2016

At first glance it would seem that the Republican Party is determined to ignore the minority vote this election year. After all, its presumptive nominee is a man with unprecedented unfavorable ratings among Blacks, Latinos and other communities of color. Recent polls have indicated that as many is 91 percent of African Americans and 77 percent of Hispanic Americans currently view Donald Trump negatively.

It’s hard to imagine a Republican victory in November, if an effective outreach strategy is not developed. To add insult to injury, many looked at post-election demographic analysis in the aftermath of the 2012 election and took note of about 7 to 8 million “missing” white voters. It seemed that — when compared to 2008 turnout and adjusting for population growth — a huge number of white voters stayed home.

As Sean Trende of RealClearPolitics explained, “The increased share of the minority vote as a percent of the total vote [in the 2012 presidential election] is not the result of a large increase in minorities in the numerator, it is a function of many fewer whites in the denominator.” Many assumed that these missing white voters were conservative evangelicals who stayed home because of Romney’s Mormonism. (Although to be fair, Trende directly refuted this assertion in his original article.) The instant “conventional wisdom” became that the Republican Party could win a national election in 2016 — without making significant inroads with minority voters. If you buy that logic, a candidate like Trump — with wide appeal to the white working class — would have a clear path to victory.

Unfortunately, even if Trump should win the White House, a whites-only campaign strategy would hurt the GOP in the long term. The demographic trends in America are clear.

The white majority in America will be gone by 2043. By 2020, the majority of American children will be non-white.

Stanford University sociologist Corey Fields recently made a study of black Republicans and noted that most of the African Americans he talked to who identified as members of the Republican party were what he called “race-conscious.” He found that they viewed their race as a more important part of their identity than the “color-blind” image he perceived from the party on a national level. In addition to citing RNC rhetoric, Fields pointed to three black Republican leaders — former presidential candidate Ben Carson, Utah Congresswoman Mia Love and South Carolina Senator Tim Scott — as being “color-blind” in their both rhetoric and policy positions.

Dr. Carson aside, it is probably worth noting that Love represents Utah’s 4th Congressional District, which is just 1.4 percent black. Senator Scott, on the other hand, has been a consistently vocal advocate for criminal justice reform, school choice and economic opportunity in struggling urban areas. Most recently, he proposed a measure that would incentivize both businesses and individuals to invest in low-income communities. I believe that Mr. Trump would do substantially better with blacks, if he followed Tim Scott’s example.

So Fields’ critique of these individuals that, “The message from the current crop of successful black Republicans is that conservative politics is at odds with black identity,” does not seem quite fair. What Blacks and Hispanics need are a few trustworthy messengers who can translate their world view into Millennial and Generation X language. Reflective blacks can also be wooed by strong economic policies and urban friendly “straight talk.” Unfortunately, many White Republicans on a national level struggle to speak about race, defaulting to language that implies minorities must lose some of their cultural distinctiveness to “fit” with the party. As Fields puts it, “The GOP presents a party where you have to choose: Be black or be a Republican.”

Now, more than ever, it is vital that conservatives play the long game. Minority newspapers and radio outreach will cost a fraction of the cost per thousand outreach dollars earmarked for this election cycle alone. Retail politics in urban America must be seen as the new guerrilla warfare for conservatives.

From now on, winning over minorities will never be a single-election cycle proposition. It must be about advancing ideas, offering alternative viewpoints, and combating the media-generated myth that conservatives are racists and that intrusive government policies are somehow beneficial to minorities. I believe that the time is now for the Republican Party to demonstrate that governing according to its principles will benefit every American, regardless of color. But in the long run, it will be up to Republicans themselves. To answer the question posed in my title, I do not believe that Donald Trump is a racist.

A bigger question is, “How badly does he want to win?” Next week, I will discuss practical steps all Republicans can take to make their party more appealing to a wider variety of voters.

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • Paul Burgett

    Well written article Harry! Thanks for not making it seem like white people are evil while addressing the real issue of under-representation of minorities by elected officials.
    “When the righteous rule, the people rejoice.”

    • fred2

      My one gripe is Bishop Jackson not acknowledging the growing number of Black people (pastors, celebrities, etc.) who openly support Trump. That’s unusual for a Republican candidate.

      What’s going on?

      In USA Today, liberal commentator Tavis Smiley explained a combination of Trump’s celebrity, fiscal policies and anti-amnesty stance strikes a deeper chord with Black voters than a typical Republican. He then warned liberals this edge could enable Trump to win.

      Another commentator Van Jones added that Trump’s social media savvy also works to his advantage.

      We will see what happens in November.

  • He may not be a racist but his campaign has sure done a dandy job of recruiting them.

    • fred2

      If Trump is racist, why did Charles Evers (brother of Merger Evers) endorse him?

      Heck why do Tyrrell Owens, Herschel Walker, and Mike Tyson plan to vote for Trump ?

      There are Black pastors who have endorsed Trump because of his. fiscal policies? (After the failed Obama years, I can understand them voting GOP this year.)

      And let’s not forget the #Blacks4Trump group.

      Trump sounds like a real Klansman. /sarc

      • Didn’t say he was racist but heck David Dukes supports him. The black folks that support him are small in numbers

        • fred2

          The Grand Dragon of CA’ s KKK endorsed Hillary. So I guess Blacks shouldn’t support her.

          As for Blacks voting Trump, Tavis Smiley noted in a USA Today column that he was surprised by how many Blacks he knew supported the GOP candidate. Naturally, Smiley warned Democrats really are underestimating Trump’s chances.

          On Facebook, Van Jones added that 30% of Blacks agree with Trump’s platform. If half that number go Trump, Hillary loses.

          • Snopes declared that the KKK endorsement was false.

          • fred2

            You’re right on that point.

            However, would you concede that Trump disavowed the Duke endorsement?

          • I wouldn’t concede to that idea.

          • fred2

            Why not?

            After all, there are news reports of Trump disavowing Duke.

Inspiration
The Strangely Mysterious Beauty of Christmas
Tom Gilson
More from The Stream
Connect with Us