The Weinstein Horror Story: Hollywood Protects a Predator

By Al Perrotta Published on October 11, 2017

What do Angelina Jolie, Mira Sorvino and Gwyneth Paltrow all have in common? They’ve each won an Oscar and each just admitted they too were sexually harassed by Hollywood producing mogul Harvey Weinstein. 

“I thought you were my Uncle Harvey,” Paltrow remembers thinking after Weinstein tried massaging her and invited her into his bedroom. She left. 

Reading their accounts in The New York Times, Paltrow, Jolie and Sorvino got off lucky. A New Yorker magazine profile out today recounts three women alleging they were raped by Weinstein and four more who were groped. (They join actress Rose McGowan, who had already gone public with her rape allegation against Weinstein.)

The list that seemingly grows by the minute of actresses, models, employees, waitresses harassed and groped and threatened by Weinstein display a pattern of sexual abuse that stretches back decades. 

The Operative Word

“Pattern” is the operative word. Weinstein’s abuse routine was practically rote. “The encounters they recalled followed a similar narrative,” The New York Times said.

First, the actresses said, Harvey Weinstein lured them to a private place to discuss films, scripts or even Oscar campaigns. Then, the women contend, he variously tried to initiate massages, touched them inappropriately, took off his clothes or offered them explicit work-for-sex deals. 

The New Yorker expose goes into further detail. It explains how Weinstein would often have a female employee with him at the start of the meeting to help the young woman feel more comfortable. The employee would then leave.

The New Yorker’s Ronan Farrow reported that 16 former and current executives at The Weinstein Company and Miramax admit either witnessing or knowing of Weinstein’s unwanted sexual advances. “All sixteen said the behavior was widely known within both Miramax and the Weinstein Company.”

The complicity gets to the most disturbing question of all, “Who knew and why’d they stay silent so long?”

Who Knew?

The answer is “most everybody.” “This has been an open secret to many in Hollywood and beyond,” writes The New Yorker. 

The Company

The cover-up starts within the film companies he ran, Miramax and the Weinstein Company. As the Times wrote: 

He had an elaborate system reliant on the cooperation of others: Assistants often booked the meetings, arranged the hotel rooms and sometimes even delivered the talent, then disappeared, the actresses and employees recounted. They described how some of Mr. Weinstein’s executives and assistants then found them agents and jobs or hushed actresses who were upset.

The Industry

So widespread was the awareness, it was even joked about at the Academy Awards. Reports the Times, “His alleged behavior became something of a Hollywood open secret: When the comedian Seth McFarlane announced Oscar nominees in 2013, he joked, ‘Congratulations, you five ladies no longer have to pretend to be attracted to Harvey Weinstein.'”

The audience laughed. The same audience of A-Listers that is now tweeting their shock and outrage. “And the Oscar for Best Feigned Surprise goes too … ”

Similarly, Maureen Callahan at the NY Post recounts,

Not everyone knew? Tina Fey knew. Back in 2012, Fey’s sitcom 30 Rock made direct reference. “I’m not afraid of anyone in show business,” Jane Krakowski’s character said. “I turned down intercourse with Harvey Weinstein on no less than three occasions … out of five.”

Said Glee creator and TV producer Ryan Murphy, “Whenever he would come up in conversation (with actresses), it would always be the same ‘ick.’ All of the girls, all of the women would say that.” He took it as a “systemic” problem. 

Oscar-nominee Jessica Chastain also calls B.S. on those in town who say they didn’t know.

Ashley Judd, herself targeted by Weinstein, told the Times, “Women have been talking about Harvey amongst ourselves for a long time, and it’s simply beyond time to have the conversation publicly.” (Why’d she wait so many years? Imagine the reaction across the Heartland had it got out in 1997 that someone had messed with Naomi Judd’s little girl and Wynonna’s kid sister.)

The Media

The Media knew. Ask Sharon Waxman, founder of the industry website The Wrap. She says in 2004, The New York Times torpedoed an article she had written exposing the mogul’s sexual misconduct in Italy. It was enabled by Miramax Italy head Fabrizio Lombardo. “After intense pressure from Weinstein, which included having Matt Damon and Russell Crowe call me directly to vouch for Lombardo and unknown discussions well above my head at the Times, the story was gutted.”

Ask Rebecca Traister at She recalls an event in New York where Weinstein called her the c-word. When a colleague intervened, Weinstein pushed him down the steps and dragged him in a headlock onto Sixth Avenue. 

Such was the power of Harvey Weinstein in 2000 that despite the dozens of camera flashes that went off on that sidewalk that night, capturing the sight of an enormously famous film executive trying to pound in the head of a young newspaper reporter, I have never once seen a photo. Back then, Harvey could spin — or suppress — anything; there were so many journalists on his payroll, working as consultants on movie projects, or as screenwriters, or for his magazine.

Both Traister and The New Yorker’s Farrow talk of the various efforts of reporters over the years to get the story out, only to fail. One was Kim Masters of The Hollywood Reporter. She almost reached the “end zone,” but was done in by fear. “At the last minute, the source withdrew.” 

“The media’s white whale,” Hollywood Reporter editor-in-chief Janice Min tweeted on Thursday. “Finally, finally, finally.”

The Police

The police even knew. The NYPD even has audio of Weinstein admitting he groped a Filipina-Italian model named Ambra Battilana Gutierrez in 2015. Gutierrez had gone to the police after the incident, and she agreed to wear a wire to their next encounter.

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

Despite the admission, the Democratic District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr., decided not to press charges. A couple weeks later Weinstein’s lawyer donated $10,000 to Vance’s campaign.

Which gets to one of the reasons for the decades of silence.

The Silence 

Why didn’t anybody speak out? Several reasons.

Harvey Weinstein made people rich and famous. He could make or break careers, not only of actresses, but directors, producers, casting directors, executives, assistants. The media had motive as well. As Waxman noted, Weinstein was a major advertiser in The New York Times. As long as he was a chief engineer in Hollywood, no one wanted to derail the money and fame train. 

In a piece titled, “I’m a Coward,” Liz Meriwether writes why she stayed silent. 

What can I do about it? Who do I tell? I don’t have enough money for a lawyer. I don’t want to suddenly become unemployable because of something he chose to do to me. What if I said something and he stopped me from getting another job? So I made a decision: I chose to stay quiet. I kept working with him. As I said, I’m a coward.

Harvey Weinstein was vicious and fearsome. Weinstein and his team of high-powered lawyers would work tirelessly to crush anyone or anything that threatened to expose him. One rape victim, who had worked with Weinstein, explained to Ronan Farrow her reluctance to come forward. “He drags your name through the mud, and he’ll come after you hard with his legal team.” 

Rose McGowan wanted to press charges. However, a lawyer advised against it. She tweeted: “a (female) criminal attorney said because I’d done a sex scene in a film, I would never win against the studio head.” Instead she settled and signed a Non-Disclosure Agreement.

Weinstein was big on NDAs.

Harvey Weinstein is politically connected. Weinstein is a major player in the Democratic Party. Weinstein not only gave hundreds of thousands of dollars to candidates and the DNC, he raised even more for Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama. He hosted fund-raisers for Hillary. Michelle Obama feted him. He’d been to the Obama White House 13 times. The Obamas even sent their daughter Malia to intern with him.  

After days of silence — or should we say years —Hillary Clinton finally released a statement. 

I was shocked and appalled by the revelations about Harvey Weinstein. The behavior described by women coming forward cannot be tolerated. Their courage and the support of others is critical in helping to stop this kind of behavior.

Barack and Michelle Obama followed with a similar vague statement Tuesday evening. They did not comment on the potential danger they put their daughter in. 

We leave the last word to Rose McGowan. 

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • Hmmm…

    Living in a world where there is so much artificiality and control through money and power, there must be that unreal quality that just keeps one marching along in step. They’re the up and outs. It’s a great time for those who have it in that environment, to share the Gospel – the love, comfort and reality of the Lord.


    Weinstein is not the only abuser. Kyle Foster revealed an entire system among the film makers and actors that abused young boys and girls at private events that was going on in the mid-40’s and 50’s. These revelations are important and demonstrate the need for transformation that can only come from a vital relationship with Christ. Everything in secret will be revealed but we must continue to pray for our nation, that these revelations will lead people to see their need for Christ, and that the church will awaken to the great need to reach out with God’s Love and power to heal and restore.

  • Howard Rosenbaum

    My how the mighty have fallen. There is going to be a shortage of extra protection shades in Hollywood . To shield the sensitive eyes of those coming out of the darkness & into the bright light exposing their hypocrisy & shame. You know, the whats hidden in darkness will be brought out into the light kind of thing. I don’t want to overspiritualize but the timing of this stuff seems to correlate w/other recent revelations. I’m not referring to the Project Veritas NYT’s videos , though they may be a factor as some are reporting. I’m referring to a seemingly large part of the democratic machine , the “deep state” , ‘the “swamp”, the previous administration’s 8 yrs & everything else virtually ignored by a complicit media whose compromise is surpassed only by their hubris! Hey, Trumps victory was practically a miracle. The opposition w/their resistance rants & non stop unsubstantiated attacks on this administration are practically demonic. Come on , when the cause celeb these days are so called transgender rights , anthem kneeling posers & antifa “patriots” somethings got to give. That” something” I suspect has already begun. Seems like some light is beginning to shine upon these miscreants & their failing agendas. Could God be behind any of this ..?
    You know , That transcendent being the founders of this great nation referenced throughout this republics most cherished historic “papers of record”. I may be wrong, but I think we’re on the precipice of an almost unprecedented period of discovery. Not the ones the Mueller team is desperately hunting for either. The Harvey’s, the Hilary’s & all the other hypocrisies are taking ( or should be shortly ) a fall. Reminds me of that scriptural analogy. ” The path of the righteous is like the light of dawn, growing brighter & brighter till the full day.” Yeah, I think it’s going to be a new day in America …..

    • Howard Rosenbaum

      Oh, btw Mr Perrotta’s reporting on this debacle is spot on .

    • Becky

      Very well stated

  • KC

    The quest for stuff can blind an individual to truth, moral standards, and even dignity.

  • Chip Crawford

    It really is a shaking, revealing the instability of this system at its core, By many reports, this has been known for decades. The initial crack and succeeding ones was inevitable, and, without rancor, is a service to the nation. There is a distinct inability to spin this, which likely accounts for the delay in response by HRC and the Obamas. So far, nothing from the late night Trump bashers. It must be crimping their brain cells trying to come up with ways to blame this on Trump. This would also seem to raise hope that the same thing could happen with the criminal and abusive elements of the HRC and Democratic machines. Again, yes, those things happening in secret being shouted from the house tops. Personally, I think where the word says that God is patient concerning transgressors, giving space for them to repent and turn applies here. But eventually, when his mercy is not applied with ensuing repentance, the claims of justice must take their course.

  • m-nj

    And with all this, is it really hard to believe that there is something to the whole pizzagate/pedogate that was labeled as “fake news” by the MSM? As another commenter wrote, all that is done in secret will be brought to light.

  • Charles Burge

    I am reminded of the now-famous “Access Hollywood” recording of Donald Trump bragging about groping and assaulting women. While such talk is indeed sickening, it was clear from the beginning that the feigned outrage from the left was nothing but sheer hypocrisy. These new revelations make that all the more undeniable.

    • Chip Crawford

      I think it really needs to be pointed out about the Access H recording that it represented talk, but not the actions mentioned. Of course, various women were produced with allegations, but they were not substantiated. Mr. Trump won’t embarrass himself further by publicly admitting he was just bragging and never did those things then or currently. He tried with emphasizing the word “talk” when he referred to it, but that of course didn’t do it. Melania said she forgave him, but again, it was for the loose braggadocio. She wouldn’t have been so light on actual actions back then and certainly not if they were current. I saw his face afterwards, and the shame was real and deep. Mike Pence pulled back and watched what he would do. When he saw that shame and succeeding words, he was satisfied. Likely they talked as well. Mike Pence would not have brooked an ongoing practice or even regular talk along those lines. Yet, many have affixed that label as past and current practice.

    • sc_cannon

      It was one of the things that helped me decide to vote for Trump, that he was a real man not a weakling afraid to express he likes women sexually.

    • Chip Crawford

      We need to remember that that recording was 10 years old when released during the campaign, not recent past.

  • stan schmunk

    Trump was as bad or worse…we evangelicals are major hypocrites.

    • Chip Crawford

      Would you please speak for yourself. “we” would depend on your interpretation of evangelicals. We may not be included in your definition. And your proof on the president, please?

    • Jim Walker

      we evangelicals ? You admit you are a hypocrite ?

    • sc_cannon

      It was one of the things that helped me decide to vote for Trump, that
      he was a real man not a weakling afraid to express he likes women

  • sc_cannon

    Horray for you Al, you have proved you can be a womens rights supporter, now wasn’t that easy. Personally I am like so what? I always thought that there were a lot of wolves and casting couches involved in the entertainment biz. As Taylor Swift wrote they are the hunters and we are the foxes, women in entertainment know what they are getting into. Forget about all the people with the opposite problem of wanting love but are undesirable and can’t find any, that sadness is way to hard to deal with and not nearly as popular to talk about.

    • Dena

      This type of thing is not just happening to woman actors, but children as well.

      I watched the Documentary “An Open Secret”. It’s about child sexual abuse scandal in Hollywood. Sad that people with money and power are able to get away with preying on young actors. I hope more speak out, so things change.

Fluke or Fruit? What Our Actions Say About Our Hearts
Liberty McArtor
More from The Stream
Connect with Us