Skeptics: ‘Jesus Wasn’t Much Good.’ Jesus: ‘Your Mind is Set on the Wrong Things.’

By Tom Gilson Published on August 21, 2020

You want to know what Jesus did wrong?

  • He didn’t condemn slavery.
  • He didn’t declare women’s equality.
  • He didn’t come to set the LGBTQ free.
  • He got mad and cursed the fig tree.
  • He didn’t teach people to boil their bandages.
  • He loved self-sacrificially.

Yes, you read that last one right: Jesus was a bad example because He gave himself for others. Nothing reveals the poverty of human vanity and ego more profoundly than that.

These examples all came from skeptics trying to fend off early versions of the argument now expanded into the book Too Good to be False: that Jesus is too good, too consistent, and too unique to be legend. Atheists want to keep Him a legend, so they take aim at His goodness.

This Is Nothing New

And there’s nothing the least bit new about it. People have been unsatisfied with Jesus from the start.

In Luke 4, Jesus’ neighbors in Nazareth want Him to be their hometown boy. He told them He was there for everyone instead.

In Mark 3:21, His family wants Him to quit making a scene. He was embarrassing them. He kept right on going.

In Matthew 16:21-23, Peter explains to Him that dying can’t be part of His mission. Jesus explains back to him: “Get behind Me, Satan!”

Peter’s problem there is everyone’s problem. Jesus told him, “You are not mindful of the things of God, but the things of men.” The things of men don’t accomplish the things of God. They don’t bring true liberation.

The “Things of God”

The “things of men” would include economic or political revolution, which is what would have followed if He’d condemned slavery. It wouldn’t have helped one bit with His main mission — setting hearts free. The effect of that over time was that Christianized Europe simply and quietly brought slavery to an end.

The “things of men” would have had Him declare women identical to men in their roles and opportunities. He did something better and more important: He demonstrated that women were equal to men in their worth — that from which all other true equality must flow.

Please Support The Stream: Equipping Christians to Think Clearly About the Political, Economic, and Moral Issues of Our Day.

The “things of men” would include modern ideas of LGBTQ “freedom.” He didn’t come to enslave men and women in false, destructive distortions of marriage and morality. Setting the LGBTQ free means setting their hearts free — meaning first of all being free from sin.

The “things of men” include “looking out for number one.” The things of God include self-sacrificial love. There are weak, destructive counterfeits of this, to be sure, and they are not of God. But when Jesus went to the cross He did it in full strength of personality — just read the accounts! —  and He did it for joy (Heb. 12:1,2).

Christ’s Mission

All these people insist that Jesus shouldn’t have been on His mission. He should have been on ours instead. He should have fixed up the world the way we think it should be fixed up. They have the things of men in mind, not the things of God.

Again, though, there’s nothing new about it. He faced it all the time during his stay on earth. His friends did it about as much as His enemies. They thought He should change His mission. “Stay out of Jerusalem — they’ll kill you if you go there!” He answered by “setting his face” toward Jerusalem. And the Cross.

Has a man ever been so completely His own person? Who knew so exactly what He was there for, and wouldn’t let anything knock Him off course? Who was so completely in charge of Himself and the situation, even at His own trial, torture, and brutal execution?”

When you look to Jesus, you will hear the things of God taught. You will see the things of God in action. You will see no moral failure — except perhaps your own, measured against Him. And you’ll see the world’s true hope.


Tom Gilson (@TomGilsonAuthor) is a senior editor with The Stream and the author or editor of six books, including Too Good To Be False: How Jesus’ Incomparable Character Reveals His Reality, in which he makes the above-mentioned case that Jesus’ way is true.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Like the article? Share it with your friends! And use our social media pages to join or start the conversation! Find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, MeWe and Gab.

We Have Hope Again
Jennie Allen
More from The Stream
Connect with Us