A Majority of Republicans Think Colleges are Bad for America

The left-right split on higher education represents an opportunity for both sides.

While 72 percent of Democrats think that colleges and universities have a positive effect on the country, only 36 percent of Republicans agree.

By Alex Chediak Published on July 13, 2017

The Pew Research Center is out with a new study on how Republicans and Democrats view institutions. One of their findings really stood out: While 72 percent of Democrats think that colleges and universities have a positive effect on the country, only 36 percent of Republicans agree.

As recently as 2015 a majority of Republicans said that colleges and universities had a positive impact. But that figure has slumped by 19 points (from 54 to 36) over just two years.

Graph Republicans and College - 600

If we go back to 2010, the split in approval between Republicans and Democrats was just 7-10 points. Today it’s 36-39 points. That’s a sea change, and most of it took place in just the last two years. I think at least two factors are at play.

College “Isn’t Worth It”

Graduates in 2009 and the next few years entered a challenging job market. They were competing with seasoned veterans who were sidelined in the recession. Student debt loads crept up while starting salaries flat-lined. Many young adults had to settle for underemployment — jobs that didn’t require a college degree, let alone the particular degree the student earned.

On the left, there were calls for student loan forgiveness and free college. Republicans questioned whether college was worth it.

What happened? Student loan payments were missed. Default rates rose. And a chorus of concerns followed. On the left, there were calls for student loan forgiveness and free college. These folk weren’t questioning the value of college. They were questioning what students were required to pay or borrow for college. As the recent Pew data shows, Democratic support for colleges and universities has increased from 65 percent to 72 percent since 2010.

But Republicans responded differently. They questioned whether college was worth it. A growing bureaucracy was contributing to rising costs, they said. They argued that traditional liberal arts education was being compromised by revisionist progressives. (Think courses like Lady Gaga and the Sociology of Fame instead of History of Western Civilization.) They argued that students weren’t learning very much and weren’t being prepared for the jobs in the 21st century.

Remember Senator Rubio’s comment about plumbers and philosophers? Leaders in this space began to champion alternative models, like online education, associate’s degrees in applied fields, and vocational education. Republican Governor Scott Walker from Wisconsin, himself a college drop-out, promoted competency-based degrees for working adults.

Liberal Bias

The other big piece is liberal bias. In 1989, there were two liberal professors for every conservative at colleges and universities nationwide. By 2014, the ratio had grown to six liberals for every conservative. That’s more bias than you’ll find in the bluest of blue states.

The Heterodox Academy, a group of professors who support viewpoint diversity, released an updated guide to colleges. They asked which campuses are best for students seeking exposure to diverse perspectives? Schools in the northeast — home of elite schools like Harvard, Yale and Middlebury College — placed last. The ratio of liberal to conservative faculty in that part of the country? A whopping 28 to 1.

Opportunities for Both Sides

The left-right split on higher education represents an opportunity for both sides. On the left, administrators should embrace the Chicago Principles of Free Expression. They should encourage students to practice persuasiveness with those who differ. They should work harder to hire a politically diverse faculty. College is supposed to be a place where students learn to think for themselves. Why not expose them to the best thinkers from all parts of the political spectrum?

On the left, administrations should work harder to hire a politically diverse faculty. Those on the right should resist the anti-college mindset.

Those on the right also have an opportunity. Yes, some students are better off getting an associate’s degree or learning a trade. But resist the anti-college mindset. A good college education makes sense for students who stand to benefit from the training, provided they graduate without too much debt.

Lastly, religious institutions should not be shy about their identity. There is a market for schools whose faculty care more about teaching than research — who shape the lives of their students, not just fill their minds. And there are plenty of faculty who are happy to serve at schools where they can freely express their religious convictions, while teaching students to do the same.


Dr. Alex Chediak (Ph.D., U.C. Berkeley) is a professor at California Baptist University and the author of Thriving at College (Tyndale House, 2011), a roadmap for how students can best navigate the challenges of their college years. His latest book is Beating the College Debt Trap. Learn more about him at www.alexchediak.com or follow him on Twitter (@chediak).

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • Andrew Mason

    There’s a difference between saying higher education is bad, and higher education is bad because of the prevalence of bias, opposition to diversity of viewpoints, or simple economics. The problem is many on the Left don’t see bias or lack of diversity as a bad thing, or worse, they see conservatives as somehow dangerous and ‘unAmerican’. So long as that continues to be the case fault lines will continue to grow.

  • Gary

    Everyone knows most colleges are run by liberals. That is why liberals support college. They like being able to teach their ideology to young people.

    For most people, traditional college is a bad idea. Too expensive and too dangerous.

  • The actual solution, painful though it is, is to remove all government support of ANY particular higher education institutions, thus forcing them ALL to stand on their own. If any government support is to wend its way to those institutions, it needs to be channeled through those directly paying the bills (or the loans); it’s their financial neck, so let them choose which institutions survive with the dollars available to them.

  • Charles Burge

    National Review just had an article on this topic yesterday (though I can’t find it now). They opined that the next Republican presidential candidate will probably leverage this to galvanize support among the various right-wing factions.

  • A college education is a waste of time and money for the vast majority of students. There are simply not that many jobs that truly require four years of expensive education. If high schools simply taught to the standards of fifty years ago, and enforced discipline and academic rigor among all students, this wouldn’t even be an issue.

    The simple fact of most universities being liberal/progressive breeding grounds is an additional reason to avoid the system at all costs.

    Solution – allow employers to implement skill based employment testing. This sort of thing was ruled by the courts as “racist” decades ago, because blacks and chicanos couldn’t pass the tests. Bring testing back. Boycott liberal indoctrination camps.
    We must stop ignoring reality in favor of political correctness.

If the Foundations are Destroyed, What Can the Righteous Do?
David Kyle Foster
More from The Stream
Connect with Us