Police-Enforced ‘Tolerance’ Means a Grey and Boring World

Elsecar Heritage Railway Station & Depot In Black & White, Elsecar, Barnsley, South Yorkshire 19th Feb 2017.

By Tom Gilson Published on September 12, 2018

William Briggs blogged Tuesday on a pair of astonishing tweets from the South Yorkshire police.

This police department wants people to report “hate.” People can express hate through “offensive or insulting comments, online, in person or in writing,” and either real or perceived “prejudice or hostility.” They can hate “a person’s race, religion, sexual orientation, transgender identity or disability.”

I’m sure you’ve seen the infringement of liberty this involves. You’ve noted how crazy backwards it is for a police department to say, “No one should live in fear of … being different,” while making people feel scared they’ll be hauled in by the police for saying something different.

I want to note something just as important.

Grey and Boring

Years ago some friends of mine produced a children’s book and cassette (now on YouTube) called “Tune Kids: The Adventure Begins.” It’s the tale of five kids whose hot-air balloon crash lands in a sad, grey land called “Greyore.” There “everything is shades of grey; there’s no color anywhere.”

My poor daughter always hated the signature grey-land song, “Grey and Boring.” In the song’s defense, it does capture the mood of Greyore:

“Grey and boring, grey and boring,
Everything around me is grey and boring.
All the rocks and trees are grey and boring,
Everything I see is grey and boring.
Nothing interests me because it’s all so boring,
Yuck! Yuck! Yuck!

That’s the kind of world the PC police want to force us to live in.

No Room to Think Differently

Think I’ve got it backward? Think I’ve missed the part where the South Yorkshire police are all in for differences in race, religion, sexual orientation, gender and ability? No, I see that. What I don’t see is any room for different opinions. Different preferences. Different beliefs.

Religion is on the list, but look carefully. There’s no positive freedom expressed there, only negative prohibitions. This isn’t freedom to act or think as one believes, it’s a police order not to talk about certain things. In fact it’s an order to agree with everyone on these issues.

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

Just look: Is there room to prefer different modes of sexual expression? No; we must all think the same way about these things. Is there room to prefer Christianity over Islam, or vice versa? No; we must consider them equal, at least in public. That is, you might be able to think that Muslims have a false understanding of Jesus Christ.

If you say it, though, that could be “perceived” as “prejudice or hostility.” Someone reports you, and off you go in the paddy wagon.

No one is allowed to disagree on any of these things.

No Difference of Opinion Allowed

You must agree. I must agree. All must agree. We must all look alike. We must all speak alike. We must all act alike. Grey and boring, grey and boring, everything around me is grey and boring.

The Tune Kids wanted desperately to get out of Greyore. No wonder. I’d want to get out of South Yorkshire just as bad. Who wants to live in a world where police tell everyone to think the same way?

Yuck! Yuck! Yuck!

It’s so bad, even a children’s song shows it up. There’s something not quite human about this land of Greyore, and something just as inhuman about the South Yorkshire requirements.

But it’s all a sham, isn’t it? Read the bottom of the tweet’s graphic again: “No one should have to live with fear, anxiety or consequences of being ‘different.’” Well, I’m different. Does that apply to me? I think there’s something wrong with homosexual behavior. I think there’s something sadly, unfortunately disordered in the minds of men who think they’re women. I think Muslims have a wrong view of Jesus Christ.

A Free World

But I want to live in a world where Muslims and gays and trans people feel free to tell me they think I’m wrong, too. I want a world where they have enough courage of their convictions, enough confidence in their positions, not to require police protection against my opinion.

That’s my preference. It’s probably different from some others’. It’s a difference that’s not allowed in South Yorkshire, though. If I lived there I’d certainly have to face down the fear of being “different.” Someone would be watching, waiting to report me. And then would come the police, and that’s when it’s clear, this is far worse than Greyore.

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • TheSaint4JC

    This is the religion of the Anti-Christ and One-World system…. It’s called Universalism in which nobody’s beliefs are superior to another’s… every belief is equally weighted and cannot reject differing viewpoints… where we all live in peace and harmony….

    1 Thes. 5:3

  • m-nj

    “Mr. Policeman… that person said something that hurt my feelings. Wah! Wah! Wah!”

    What is this world coming to? Grownups acting like children tattling on each other over words? Orwell’s 1984 comes to mind.

  • GLT

    Perhaps I am confused but isn’t enforced tolerance an oxymoron?

    • Ben Welliver

      Uh, yeah.

  • Chip Crawford

    Due process anyone?

  • Trilemma

    Officer, every single one of all these people in this long line in front of me said something that greatly hurt my feelings. Please, make the all leave.

    • Ken Abbott

      That’s certainly one way to speed things up.

    • Andrew Mason

      And that is the paradox. The liberal jihad against hate is perversely simply a means of securing privilege and persecuting those they deem untouchable.

      • Trilemma

        I agree. My comment was aimed at the idea that highly subjective laws will be gamed by individuals for their own benefit.

        • Exactly the intention of you wanting people to turn into nihilist blobs driven exclusively by marxist talking points.

    • Dreaming of “utopia?”

  • David N. Gray

    But “hate” and “disagreement” are not at all the same thing. We should be able to disagree with what someone says or disapprove of what they do without hating them or threatening them. Sure, some people may feel that mere criticism is “offensive or insulting”, but (giving the benefit of the doubt) I think the intended point of the police post (which could have been better worded) was about behavior which would make people feel that they are in danger. We don’t want to be doing that.

    • 2Hònest

      I think the reason these people equate disagreement with hate is that they themselves hate those they disagree with. They assume that we are like them.

    • Bryan

      See, you’re using the rational and reasoning part of your brain. This type of thinking doesn’t come from that part of the brain. It generally comes from the feeling and emotional part. Which means that, for however much good intent there was in creating this post, it’s implementation can irrational and subjective.

  • swordfish

    For once, I agree with you. This tweet from South Yorkshire Police is completely laughable. If you read the Twitter comments underneath it, they’re almost 100% disagreeing with it, sometimes in hilariously forthright manner. I apologise on behalf of my country for this BS.

    • Ken Abbott

      No apologies required, swordfish. But I am curious as to why/how this oversensitivity has been embraced by local councils and law enforcement in many parts of the UK. It clearly does not represent the views of the populace at large.

  • Samsquanch

    Dear UK, You guys held back actual Nazis. What happened?

Inspiration
Christianity Works Only in Its Most Radical Form
Dudley Hall
More from The Stream
Connect with Us