Is the Trump/Russia “Dossier” the Fake News of the Decade?

By William M Briggs Published on January 11, 2017

Fake news or conspiracy theory? Or the most epic troll since Dan Rather was conned into accepting forged documents about George Bush? Or a hilarious amalgam of all three?

All elements of this story are as yet unknown, but what is unfolding has the makings of historical high comedy. Here’s a rundown.

Buzzfeed, a website whose specialty is celebrity tittle-tattle, asinine quizzes such as “Which ‘Pixie Hollow Fairy Are You?“, and get-skinny-quick-by-petting-cats articles, published a document, which they gave the graduated title of dossier, which purported to show how Russia, under the devious and genius scheming of Vladimir Putin, had been grooming and bribing Donald Trump for many years, and blackmailing him by threatening to reveal perverted sexual practices, so that Trump would be induced to enter the US Presidential election, win it by secret dirt supplied by Russian intelligence agents, and so place the once United States of America under the control of a foreign government.

Yes, really.

Even Hollywood would never believe a story like that. But many others did. Like, some allege, virulent Never-Trumper, and legacy Republican political strategist, Rick Wilson, the man who accused Trump supporters (this is, unfortunately, relevant) of being childless single men who masturbate to anime.

That disgusting comment is relevant because after Wilson made it, he became a target of ridicule across the Internet, including at the Wild West site 4Chan, a place were folks delight in trolling, which might be defined as pranking-with-intent. After Buzzfeed revealed their conspiracy theory, and probably because of the conspiracy theory’s reliance on certain perverted sexual acts and because of Wilson’s tie-in with sexual commentary, members on 4chan claimed that they were the authors of the dossier. The claim is that the dossier was fan fiction, and that it was leaked to Wilson who believed it and who then turned it over to the CIA. Wilson denies this. And it isn’t plausible 4chan hoaxed the entire USA intelligence community, but the fracas adds a delightful twist to the story.

A better angle involves Republican Senator John McCain, personal enemy of Trump. McCain was first given a copy of the conspiracy document, which he later handed over to the FBI because, he said, he didn’t “know if it is credible or not.”

How did McCain come into possession of the document in the first place? It is being reported he got it from Christopher Steele, an Ex-British Intelligence Officer, and member of Orbis Intelligence Limited, a company that performs “oppo research,” or opposition research, also known as the art of digging up dirt. Yet if it is true Steele is the author of the conspiracy theory, who paid Steele to create it?

The Wall Street Journal tried tracking down Steele, but they only discovered a colleague who told the paper Steele “would be away for a few days.” The colleague didn’t know where. Perhaps they should search in Phoenix, where Senator McCain has his official residence? Or maybe in a dim bar in Moscow? One wonders if Steele has a 4chan account. Never mind.

Enter CNN. That network presented the conspiracy theory as if it were true, and hinted with all possible strength that the US intelligence community also believed it was true, and that Trump had been briefed by “Intel chiefs” about the damning information Russia had on him.

Only it turns out that Trump was never briefed. Intelligence agencies had the document, which is now known to have been “originally generated as part of opposition research by anti-Trump Republicans and then shopped by Democrats,” but they “planned to show it as an example of disinformation campaigns.”

The tale grows stranger still, because Trump himself claims to have conducted his own “sting operation” to detect leaks from American intelligence agencies, an operation he says was a success, proving somebody was leaking details about his intelligence briefings. This has led to all kinds of rumors about bad feelings between Trump and the intelligence community.

Reacting to CNN and Buzzfeed, Trump said at a news conference Wednesday, “It’s all fake news. It’s all phony stuff. It didn’t happen.” The kicker is that when a CNN reporter tried to ask a question, Trump shot him and CNN down, saying “You are fake news.”

CNN has not given up its visceral hatred of Trump, and has proved willing to broadcast any information that might be damaging to Trump.

It will be recalled that during the election, CNN had given up any pretence of impartiality, openly touting Clinton and denigrating Trump. The network’s bias soon became so blatant that when a CNN crew was spotted, Trump supporters taunted them with cries of “Clinton News Network,” or worse.

Now that Hillary has faded from the scene, CNN has not given up its visceral hatred of Trump, and has proved willing to broadcast any information that might be damaging to Trump, even when that information has less veracity than an out-of-focus photograph which purports to show Bigfoot riding the Loch Ness Monster.

The story isn’t over. The news on why Steele wrote the document, if he wrote it, and why, including who paid him for it, is bound to generate even more fun.

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • 6Proverbs16

    Actually, Trump’s proclaiming, and funding, claims that Mr Obama was not an American – for many years! – is FAKEyer, and STUPIDyer, and NASTYer.

    • Alfdog

      NBC reported Trump did not see the dossier according to the CiA. The CIA said it was brought to show Trump what disinformation looks like. They never got around to the topic of disinformation so it was never shown, according to NBC.

  • Linda

    And it’s inconceivable that Putin and the Russian spy agency originated the 35 pages of reports, because after all, they said they didn’t, and vowed that their modus operandi never involves creating compromising information on western figures. So there, it’s settled. The reports are surely written by American or allied enemies.

    • Alfdog

      It’s settled because the CIA says there is NO evidence to prove the unfounded accusations by senator John Mcains private intelligence spy.

      • Linda

        Oh ya? What is the FBI investigating then?

  • Wayne Cook

    “Is the Trump/Russia “Dossier” the Fake News of the Decade?” Pretty much. And the comments below simply add straw to the pile. Not one of the people in the list has an microsecond of time in any of the agencies.

  • Perhaps the fake news of the century.

  • SophieA

    So this whole notion of “fake news” has bothered me since it appeared on my radar sometime during the presidential campaign. Who renamed “propaganda” and “misinformation” as “fake news” and to what purpose? All countries employ propaganda and misinformation and spy on each other even on our allied regimes. Why has this “fake news” risen to this super high boiling fervor when not a peep was uttered by these same “news” outlets when the Obama administration actively lobbied to oust Israel’s leader and to keep the U.K. in the European Union (just to name two instances of many)? Perhaps CNN and Buzzfeed will realize their mistake, but I’ll not hold my breath. If it weren’t so sad that our national political discourse has sunk well below creepy tabloid trash not fit to print, I might look forward to this “story’s” fun, future developments.

    • Dodgy Geezer

      Actually, the fake news with regard to Obama and Brexit is that Britain would be ‘at the back if the line’ when applying for trade deals. Turns out that Trump wants the UK at the Front.

      However, all of this pales into insignificance when you remember that the Pope and the ArchBishop of Canterbury (Head of the Church of England) both said that GOD wants the UK to stay in the EU. That sounds like the false news of the decade to me…

  • Jim Faller

    Or is it real and by calling it fake news now make it hard for Americans to believe if it is found to be true.

Inspiration
God Has Come to Us
Sheila Walsh
More from The Stream
Connect with Us