Fluke or Fruit? What Our Actions Say About Our Hearts

"So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit. A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit." Matthew 7:17-18

By Liberty McArtor Published on July 16, 2018

Calling out problems on a cultural level is easy. There’s lots of room to extend your arm and point your finger. Turning that finger around and pointing it at yourself is awkward and uncomfortable. 

So for a long time, I pointed at others, calling out their lack of civility. It was usually in general terms. “Our society needs to be more civil.” “People should try listening to each other instead of bashing each other.” “Christians should be more loving toward each other when they disagree.” 

I even wrote some articles about it. Last year I wrote about Foster Friess’s Return to Civility initiative. I wrote about a former neo-Nazi who covered his racist tattoos after his black parole officer showed him kindness. I wrote about Black Lives Matter protesters sharing a moment of civil dialogue with Trump supporters in Washington, D.C. I wrote about being civil in our online interactions, and endeavored to exemplify such civility in my own social media posts.

Advocating Civility vs. Living It

Since I was pounding the civility beat in my writing, surely I was exemplifying it in my personal life, right? I did love talking about the issue with friends and colleagues — in an abstract, theoretical, “if only” sort of way.

But what happened when I packed up my work bag, shut down my computer and hopped in the car to head home? There was anger, uncharitable comments and perhaps a few obscene gesticulations. Well, that’s just traffic, right? You’re anonymous when you’re behind the wheel. No big deal. 

We can advocate for good values all day long, but it’s just a show if our own lives aren’t producing the same fruit we try to sell.

But what about when I stopped at the grocery store or a drive through, and the service was extra slow? The order messed up? The cashier annoying? There was chilliness, impatience, maybe a passive aggressive complaint. Okay, now we’re getting a little less anonymous. But still, it’s not like they knew me — or what I’d written.

What about when I talked to loved ones and they did something to make me mad — even something as simple as advocate a position I disagreed with? There was snarkiness, frustration, and in the worst cases, insults, thinly veiled and not veiled at all. There’s no anonymity at that point. My behavior was not only hypocritical, but boldly so. 

Fruit, Not a Fluke

Thankfully the Lord began convicting me about this. You can’t decide you’re going to advocate civility in your writing, and then conduct yourself like an angry maniac on the highway. It’s insincere to show civility to people online if you’re going to glare at the grocery store cashier. 

So why do we do that? Why did I do that? The Bible has some things to say about it. 

“The good person out of the good treasure of his heart produces good, and the evil person out of his evil treasure produces evil, for out of an abundance of the heart his mouth speaks.” Luke 6:45

“So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit. A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit.” Matthew 7:17-18

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

My bursts of road rage or disagreeableness toward those I loved were not flukes. They were fruit. They were the evidence of what kind of treasure was in my heart. And it wasn’t pretty. My heart was diseased, and any public advocating I did for healthy things like civility was just a show. 

Through this lesson I realized that the best way to address a cultural problem is to start by pointing our fingers at ourselves. We can advocate for good values all day long — civility, churchgoing, pro-life activism, etc. — but it’s just a show if our own lives aren’t producing the same fruit we try to sell. 

God, may we honor you in our actions, no matter how anonymous they may seem. Please search and renew my heart so that it produces fruit that is pleasing to you. Amen. 

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • Sandi Kyle

    Thank you, Liberty. This was a good article and certainly in line with what the Lord has revealed to me about my own heart. I take a “little” comfort in knowing that this is common, as the enemy wants to isolate us and cause us to believe that we’re the only hypocritical Christian around and what a slime bucket we are. May we all cry out to God in repentance so that our hearts can be filled with his love, and then pour out that same love onto those all around us, anonymously or not.

  • John

    Your article is a blessing. Thanks.
    I wanted to share an amazing thing that happened to me and my wife. We went to church as usual. We were a little late and worship had already begun. The place was almost full. We found two seats (not together) and began maneuvering past the other worshipers down toward them. There was a woman (we did not know personally) occupying a single seat between two vacant ones. My wife tapped the woman on the shoulder to ask if she might move down to give us two adjacent seats. Instantly the woman stretched out her arms and, with a smile on her face, gave my wife a big hug.
    May not sound like much; however we were ending one of the roughest weeks of our lives. We had received grave news from the doctor. News that included the dreaded “C” word. At the instant she hugged my wife it was as if the angels of heaven joined for a group hug. We were flooded with comfort from the Holy Spirit. It was supernatural! I will never forget it for the rest of my life! Who could know what a blessing a simple random act of kindness could bring. It made me think about my behavior and consider what damage a random act of unkindness may do. I believe eternity is truly changed by our actions. May our actions be Godly.


  • Andrew Mason

    Is it that your public advocacy for civility was a show, or that there was a mismatch between your head and your heart? The fact you know something to be right doesn’t mean you’ll (always) do it. And it’s only if you claim to be that which you advocate whilst consistently refusing to do what you claim that you’re guilty of hypocrisy. Not suggesting I’m any less guilty of course, and some situations etc do tend to try one’s patience!!!

  • Tim H

    Good reminders to all of us that small indicators mark our way along the path of holiness. Reminds me of Therese of Lisieux’s little way of holiness.

Is Your Heart Heavy? God Knew It Would Be
Charles Spurgeon
More from The Stream
Connect with Us