Does Supporting President Trump Hurt the Gospel? Andy Stanley Says Yes. Here Is Why I Disagree.

By Shane Idleman Published on November 16, 2020

The divide in our nation among Christians seems to be fueled primarily by misinformation and false narratives. I believe that God is allowing these differences so we can practice Scripture and love those we disagree with, but some are taking it too far. Andy Stanley, for example, commented that leaders who align with Trump actually hurt the Church’s ability to reach people outside the Church.

Decisions Based on Fear

I’m assuming that Andy’s thought process goes something like this: “When you support someone like Trump, you alienate people and turn them off to the gospel.” In order to gain insight into this point of view, I recently spent time with Christians who take this position. Though I left that meeting with a better understanding of how people feel, I was more convinced than ever of the dangers of allowing our feelings to outweigh objective truth. We can’t make decisions based on the fear that something will offend; we must make decisions based on what is right.

Is It Really Our Goal to Avoid Offending Others?

The view that says supporting the President hurts our witness is flawed in three ways: 1) When people who can support President Trump don’t, by default they support the opposing views. You can’t have your cake and eat it too. 2) How can we protect the unborn, bring back God’s Word in many areas of society, and not legalize perversion if we remain neutral? We can’t. 3) The view that you can’t support Trump attempts to scrutinize character rather than policy. Obviously, character is important, but, if a man who has decent character (according to some) is taking America in a very dangerous direction, do we look at his character over his policies? Of course not. Ideally they should match, but in this case policy speaks louder than character.

Suppose we take this line of thinking about hurting the gospel to its logical end. Would that also mean we shouldn’t speak out against abortion, because it might hurt our witness to physicians who perform them? Or what about the parent who had an abortion — should we not mention any pro-life positions because it might offend them? No, it’s okay to speak the truth in love, and then offer hope as I did here in “The Day I Told My Daughter about My Abortion Decision.” Offering hope elevates the gospel.

If you’re walking on eggshells and gauging every word carefully so as not to offend, your speech will be spiritually impotent. We have too many cowards, too few Spirit-filled leaders. As Leonard Ravenhill said, “We have too many puppets in our pulpits and not enough prophets.” Would ‘Woke’ Christians Rebuke Jesus?

Follow the Biblical Example

Would these Christians tell Jesus not to call the religious leaders “whitewashed tombs”and “vipers” because it could hurt His witness to them (Matthew 23:23, 27)? Would they tell Jesus not to say, “A worse thing will come upon you unless you repent,” (John 5:14) because it would turn His hearers off? Or would they caution Him against offending His audience when He said, “Don’t fear them who can kill the body; fear Him who can cast both body and soul in hell” (Matthew 10:28)? I think we all know the answer. 

In 1 Corinthians 9:22, when Paul said, “I have become all things to all people so that by all possible means I might save some,” he was being culturally relevant, not truth deficient. Our attitude shouldn’t offend others, but truth will. We should be more concerned about God’s opinion than popular opinion. I truly believe that a lack of boldness in the pulpit (and the pew) is the result of failing to spend sufficient time alone with God while allowing His Word to empower us. Instead of having our spiritual guns of boldness being loaded in the prayer closet, we are turning into passive cowards, covering our lack of boldness with political spins and worldly excuses.

Proclaim the Word of God

We must preach the difficult truths to set people free. The church cannot neglect, water down, or avoid preaching hard things because it might offend. Oswald Chambers reminds us that “the words of the Lord hurt and offend until there is nothing left to hurt and offend.” The gospel hurts before it helps; it condemns before it releases. To remove everything that offends is to remove the very foundation of the gospel.

The goal of preaching is to faithfully proclaim the Word of God, and not worry about “crowd appeal.” The church  as a whole may have forgotten this vital truth, but it doesn’t follow that you and I should. We need to be “woke” to the things of God and “cancel” cowardliness.

For more, watch a short clip here on not remaining silent, and watch last week’s sermon, I Pour Out My Soul To You, here.


Shane Idleman is the founder and lead pastor of Westside Christian Fellowship in Southern California and the creator of the WCF Radio Network. His program, Regaining Lost Ground, points us back to God and reminds us that although times change, truth does not. His books, blogs, and sermons can all be found at Follow Shane on these platforms: Personal YouTube, Sermons on YouTube, Instagram, Twitter, Parler, Facebook, and MeWe.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Like the article? Share it with your friends! And use our social media pages to join or start the conversation! Find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, MeWe and Gab.

Military Photo of the Day: E-2 Hawkeye Launches
Tom Sileo
More from The Stream
Connect with Us