Charlottesville Has Become a Pretext for Letting Antifa Run Wild
Here’s a short quiz I’d like to see administered to every American. The results would be instructive. They’d reveal whether a person is an informed citizen who actually supports our system of government. Or just some schlump who happens to live here.
Which groups of American citizens, under the Constitution, may march publicly? Which may express their views without being forcibly silenced by counterdemonstrators using home-made flamethrowers:
a) White nationalists and right-wing anti-Semites.
b) ISIS supporters and Islamist anti-Semites.
c) Advocates of legalizing man-boy sexual relationships.
d) Advocates of legal abortion.
e) All of the above.
Which of the following makes someone’s views so repugnant that it’s okay, even admirable, for you to punch him for expressing it:
a) It really, really offends your sense of what’s good and decent.
b) It makes you feel that your group is threatened, politically, by his group.
c) It triggers you and makes you feel emotionally unsafe.
d) It could lead souls to eternal damnation.
e) None of the above.
When is it morally acceptable for citizens to attack public or private property and destroy statues or signs because they think they represent evil ideas:
a) When it honors someone from the past whom you judge guilty of racism.
b) When it represents a religion you think is oppressive to women and gays.
c) When it advertises abortion clinics, or pornographic materials.
d) When it constitutes an idol forbidden by the First Commandment.
e) None of the above.
The job of public authorities in dealing with public demonstrations is:
a) To silence views that are offensive or contrary to American values.
b) To protect the interests of historically disenfranchised groups against stronger groups.
c) To let both sides fight it out on the streets, then arrest just the members of the less politically popular or elite-connected group.
d) To promote the true religion and destroy false religions.
e) To allow everyone who is not directly threatening violence or advocating the forcible overthrow of the U.S. government to express his views, protected from vigilante censorship.
The greatest threat to free expression and public order in America today is:
a) White nationalists and neo-Nazis.
b) Radical leftists such as Antifa.
c) Sharia Muslims and Islamists.
d) Atheists and heretics.
e) Public authorities who selectively enforce the laws and allow groups of violent citizens to silence other citizens by force.
The American answer, in every case, is e). Any other answer, whatever the motive for offering it, is a step down the path to civil war.
How to Avoid the Spanish Civil War in America
I support the right of abortionists, white racists, ISIS supporters, and the North American Man Boy Love Association, to march down our country’s streets in public demonstrations. I will not go to New York City and tear down the street signs marking “Margaret Sanger Place,” honoring that eugenicist. Nor do I tear down subway ads or hack websites that provide abortion information. Nor do I believe in harassing, threatening, or terrorizing abortionists. Or pornographers. Or even liberal Jesuits.
I support the right of abortionists, white racists, ISIS supporters, and the North American Man Boy Love Association, to march down our country’s streets in public demonstrations.
Why? First for the very pragmatic reason that I don’t want them doing the same to me. There are millions of people in this divided country with radically opposed views of the Good. Many of them might find my views as repugnant as I find theirs. I don’t want them targeting me, so I won’t target them. That’s where it starts. With a recognition that first of all we need to keep the peace. From that we can move on upward to principled defense of people’s free speech rights based on their divinely-made human dignity. But the pragmatic argument should be enough.
Anarchy protects nobody’s rights, except those of the strongest. Following your moral outrage to the point where you will use violence is a great way to turn the United States into Libya, Syria, or Venezuela. There nobody is protected.
Or as I’d say to any leftist wearing a “Punch More Nazis” t-shirt: “Can I wear a shirt saying that about abortionists? They’re not just fantasizing about it. They’re actually killing people, every day.” Once we go down that road, there are no offramps. There’s no shoulder on that road. It leads with icy certainty to just one exit: civil war.