That Giant Liberty-Sucking Sound From the Tolerant Left

In this screengrab from video, Jack Phillips works on a cake at his bakery, Masterpiece Cakeshop, in Colorado.

By David Limbaugh Published on December 22, 2018

Various leftist grievance groups have insisted for years that they just want equal treatment and equal rights, that they only want to end discrimination and that they come with an attitude of “live and let live.” Nope.

We’ve long known that the “tolerance” police don’t merely want equal rights and to be treated with civility. They require that you honor their ideas as superior, reject your own contrary ideas and do penance for ever having held your own ideas.

No Tolerance

If you make the mistake of dissenting from their dogma, you must be shamed — and punished. There is no semblance of tolerance in their bones. They are militantly aggressive and spoiling for any opportunity to pressure and intimidate people into submission. This suppression of our liberties doesn’t just emanate from the government; the long arm of the private sector often enforces uniformity of thought with the same coercive power.

Jack Phillips Targeted

Let me give you just a few examples of probably hundreds, perhaps thousands. Do you remember Jack Phillips, the poor Christian owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop in Colorado, the baker who refused to make a wedding cake for a gay couple because it would have violated his religious convictions? He didn’t deny them service, mind you, but would not bow to their demand that he prepare a cake to celebrate their wedding.

The complaining couple weren’t being harmed. They could have gone anywhere else to purchase a custom-made wedding cake. But they refused to allow this baker to exercise his religious liberty. This surely was a deliberate targeting of a Christian baker to force him to conform to their values and thought edicts.

Though the Supreme Court held that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission had violated Phillips’ First Amendment liberties, he is being harassed again — this time by Denver attorney Autumn Scardina, for refusing to bake a custom-ordered cake to celebrate her transition from male to female. The commission has predictably ruled that Phillips was guilty of discrimination. Are you kidding me?

Again, Phillips is being targeted. His attorneys aptly describe it as an “obvious setup.” Christian liberties must be subordinated to bizarre leftist ethical standards. We’ll see how this nightmare unfolds in the coming months.

Kevin Hart and the Leftist Bullies

Another egregious example of leftist intolerance that caught my eye was actor and comedian Kevin Hart’s being bullied into stepping down from his role as host of the upcoming Academy Awards. After he was selected for the role, critics savaged Hart for allegedly homophobic tweets he had made almost a decade ago, and for saying during a 2010 special, “Seriously Funny,” that as a heterosexual male, he would prevent his son from being gay if he could. Though he initially refused to apologize and insisted he had matured since he made those remarks (which he said were jokes), just hours later he announced he would decline to host and offered his apology “to the LGBTQ community for (his) insensitive words from (his) past.”

But Hart’s public repentance, apology and stepping down from the gig weren’t enough. There would be no forgiveness, even for a sincere apology.

Brandi Miller, in a column for HuffPost, said that even after apologizing for being insensitive and saying he was evolving, Hart “still misses the point.” According to Miller, Hart’s critics “are challenging his professed evolution. Can he show that he’s realized that he harmed people and make right on the harm that he caused? Apparently not.”

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

Even a “sincere apology” wouldn’t clear him. “A true apology, a true acknowledgment of harm done from Hart would involve talking about the implications of his words,” said Miller, “not just apologizing for who he used to be. … Apologizing is like a math problem. To get the credit, you have to show your work. … Let’s be honest, tweeting ‘I apologize’ isn’t that hard and doesn’t really involve much internal reckoning, but with his actions, he can show a changed life.”

What “work” would Miller have Hart do to earn his redemption? Miller suggested he could have donated money to LGBTQ organizations or requested an LGBTQ-identifying co-host (or even host) for the Academy. As I said, get him down and kick him, and then neuter him.

Another columnist piled on in USA Today, saying Hart should become a stronger comic, scrapping his “homophobic jokes” — which he had already scrapped, by the way — and “make a 20-minute killer set about his homophobic fears.” There you go. He can’t just apologize; he must affirmatively adopt the critics’ vision, even to the point of changing his entire routine. Don’t just back off the subject of homosexuality; embrace it and say how much you love it and say that you now regard it as the highest possible value. Then and only then will your sins be expiated. (Even then, he’d never be unleashed and see his liberty restored. The threat of sanctions for any future infraction would always hang over his head.)

Leftist Orthodoxy

How dare dissenters from the totalitarian leftist orthodoxy think they can atone for past sins just by apologizing and demanding equal rights for everyone. They must also renounce any residual beliefs that might offend the activists. This is leftist tolerance, forgiveness and compassion.

We hear a lot of demands from a lot of groups in this country, but one ideal that is rarely touted anymore is America’s foremost founding idea — liberty. Increasingly, the modern left is gobbling up the liberties — speech, association, religion, firearms, due process — of anyone who doesn’t embrace its worldview, and liberty lovers everywhere had better wake up to this threat and do a much better job of fighting back.


David Limbaugh is a writer, author and attorney. His latest book is Jesus Is Risen: Paul and the Early Church. Follow him on Twitter @davidlimbaugh and his website at 


Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • Ray

    Please, Let’s everyone pray against the demonic stronghold of the homosexual agenda. That principality must be bound. May God wrap it up in chains, bind it with steel, shackle it’s feet and hands, punch it’s head or whatever. Pray to a take down, in the name of Jesus Christ.

    • Jim Walker

      I believe this is the start of the rot of our humanity, bringing society back to the days of Noah.
      It will only get worse. But we have God on our side. Who can overcome us? What can man do to us?

  • Lisa

    Excellent article. I hope the pendulum starts swinging back soon because it’s starting to smell like Russian gulags with leftists tell us how to think. America needs to remember we’re the land of the free and home of the brave.

  • John Chisum

    The side that preaches of tolerance and diversity is only satisfied when their views and beliefs are agreed with. Their tolerance is more like Gestapo tactics than anything.

    Unfortunately, religion and the right to life of unborn babies are not included in their doctrine.

    • Woobiefuntime

      It isn’t as cut and dry because there is some on the left who believe in silencing people .

  • Chris in NC

    These people truly are afflicted with a kind of blindness. They cannot see why someone would hold any differing beliefs on things they see as “right”. It’s not even a question of ‘maybe’ – you’re just plain wrong – or evil – if you disagree.
    And don’t even begin to talk to these folks about your vision of “right”. You will either be dismissed outright or called all sorts of vile things. I mean, how could anyone be so close-minded and -phobic (pick whatever you want, there’s tons of them).
    I truly feel sorry for these people. At least the ones I know. And I pray that someday they will hear that ‘small, still voice’ that calls to us all.

  • sharkgirl7

    Very well written! It’s as if I wrote it myself because these are EXACTLY my thoughts! Bravo!

    One mistake: Autumn is still a man and you identified him as female in your wording.

    Totally sharing this!!

Lessons from a Stolen Bike
Alex Chediak
More from The Stream
Connect with Us