After Facing Questions on Abortion, 2 Obama Judicial Nominees Fail to Advance
The Senate Judiciary Committee isΒ holding up two of President Barack Obamaβs judicial nominees for federal judgeships in Pennsylvania.
Robert Colville and John Younge, both nominatedΒ for lifetime judicial positions, did not receive a vote at Thursdayβs committee meeting. Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, said the move was meant to give senatorsΒ more time to review βtheir records and answers to written questions.β
Colville and Younge were nominated by Obama in July to serve asΒ U.S.Β district judges in Pennsylvania. Their delay comes as conservatives have calledΒ for the Republican-controlled Senate to stop confirming Obamaβs judicial nominees.
After failing to impress the committee during the confirmationΒ process, the duo isnβt likely to make it out of committee anytime soon.
In particular, some Republican committee members werenβt satisfied with either Colville or Youngeβs answers about the ability of states to regulate access to abortion.
Neither nominee initially addressed questions of abortion directly, saying instead that the controversial Roe v. Wade decision was βsettled law.β
Colville, a judge on the Court of Common Pleas for Allegheny County, indicated to the Judiciary Committee that he supported the precedent established in Roe v. Wade. Then, asked if unborn children have human rights, the judge responded, βprobably yes, but only in certain respects and manners of speaking, not all.β
Younge received questions about endorsements he received while running for the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia. While a candidate, he sought support from Planned Parenthoodβs political action committee.
Younge wouldnβt say if he would have sought that endorsement had he known of allegations that the abortion provider harvested and sold aborted babiesβ tissue. (Planned Parenthood has denied the organization is guilty of illegal activity.) Instead, he noted that there are βdisagreements as to the facts and implications of the current controversy.β
Unimpressed, both Grassley and Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., sent follow-up questions. Never a good sign for nominees, according to Senate sources, the additional evaluation could indicate chronic problems with Colville and Youngeβs nominations.
Confirmation of the judges has been a bipartisan priority for Pennsylvania Sens. Bob Casey, a Democrat, and Pat Toomey, a Republican. Last year, both senators signed their βblue-slipβ forms, completing a process to officially recommend nominations from a senatorβs home state to the Judiciary Committee.
In December, a Toomey spokesman told a Pennsylvania newspaper that the senator βhas spoken directly with Majority Leader Mitch McConnell to emphasize the importance of getting these judges confirmed as soon as possible.β
But in a prepared statement Thursday, Grassley indicated that Casey and Toomey didnβt balk at the delay. Instead, they asked that two other Pennsylvania nominees, also awaiting confirmation, advance for a vote.
The episode comes as debate continues over whether Republicans should continue to confirm Obamaβs judicial nominees during the last yearΒ of his presidency.
Proponents of the strategy, including Heritage Action for America, argue that the process should come to a halt in protest of what they consider Obamaβs executive overreach in other matters. Opponents counter that the process has already become too political.
In January, the Senate confirmed three of Obamaβs judicial nominees:Β Luis Felipe Restrepo to the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals on Jan. 11,Β Wilhelmina Wright as a federal district judge in Minnesota on Jan. 19, andΒ John Michael Vazquez asΒ a U.S. district judge in New Jersey on Jan. 27.
Last week, Sen. David Perdue, R-Ga., blocked the nomination of judicial nomineeΒ Dax Lopez to U.S. District Court in Georgia after learning of his work with a group that supports amnesty for illegal immigrants.
Perdue did this by withholding his βblue-slipβ recommendation form. As per Senate rules, a member can effectively veto home-state nominees by refusing to recommend them to the Judiciary Committee.
Copyright 2016 The Daily Signal