Advice for Your Relationship With an Apostate Family Member

By Alan Shlemon Published on August 25, 2018

I was recently asked for advice by someone whose sister is no longer claiming to be a Christian. This has caused a rift in their relationship, and she wanted to know what I would suggest. I figured I’d offer my thoughts “out loud” in case someone else is asking a similar question.

Pray for Salvation

First, I told her she should begin (if she hasn’t already) to pray for her sister’s salvation. Too often, in apologetic circles, we put too much emphasis on arguments and reason, thinking we could win over our family member if we just had a better apologetic. Don’t get me wrong, knowing apologetics can help, especially if the person is wrestling with an intellectual objection. I’m an apologist, so I’m definitely in favor of being prepared to answer questions and doubts. Many times, though, we might not know exactly what’s going on inside their soul, but God does. Besides, no person comes to faith in Christ apart from the work of the Holy Spirit. So, making prayer a priority helps us gain the right perspective. The work of salvation is the work of God alone.

Help us champion truth, freedom, limited government and human dignity. Support The Stream »

One of the things I suggested she specifically pray for is that God would bring committed believers into her sister’s life. Often our family members are resistant to our ideas, thoughts, pleas, and arguments simply because we’re their relative. I’ve often seen God bring someone else like a friend or co-worker into a person’s life who becomes a bigger influence than the family member ever could be.

Make the Relationship a Priority

My second piece of advice was to make her relationship with her sister a high priority. This might seem like obvious advice, but for some people, once their friend or family member has abandoned their walk with Christ, that relationship is relegated to second-class status. That’s a mistake, in my opinion. Relationships are a bridge by which we can tell the truth, show compassion, share the gospel, and simply share life together. They also allow us to gain people’s trust so they can become more open with us. Making your relationship with them a high priority will allow you to have a lasting impact in their life.

Allow Them to Talk

The third thing I told her was to take an evening and give her sister an opportunity to share what’s going on in her life, especially with regard to her recent spiritual changes. She should be prepared, however, to allow her sister to share the entire time. In other words, don’t plan to respond. Just give her the freedom to honestly tell her story and what’s going on inside her heart and soul without the anticipation that she’ll be answered or argued with. This will make it more likely that she’ll be open and honest, giving you a more accurate picture of her life.

Too often we think that if we have a chance to share about matters of faith, we must unload everything we know or think.

This third piece of advice is helpful for a couple of reasons. First, it will allow her to be more strategic when she prays for her sister. By better understanding what’s going on in her sister’s heart and soul (e.g. inner conflicts, doubts, fears, etc.), she can use that knowledge to ask God for help to intervene in specific ways that are relevant to her sister’s issues. Second, knowing her sister’s concerns will help her be more strategic about how she could intervene in the future, should the opportunity arise.

Not Necessarily All At Once

Realize, though, that talking to her about spiritual matters doesn’t have to occur all at once. Too often we think that if we have a chance to share about matters of faith, we must unload everything we know or think. In the case of a sister (or anyone you’re in a long-term relationship with), you usually have plenty of time and opportunities. There will probably be other chances to share additional spiritual thoughts with them.

Don’t forget, as I mentioned in my first piece of advice, that it’s not your job to make people Christian. It’s not your job to convince them of your arguments either. Your job is to be faithful to your role — being an ambassador for Christ. Share the truth in a loving, persuasive, and gracious way, and then leave the results up to God.


Copyright 2018 Stand To Reason. Republished with permission.

Print Friendly
Comments ()
The Stream encourages comments, whether in agreement with the article or not. However, comments that violate our commenting rules or terms of use will be removed. Any commenter who repeatedly violates these rules and terms of use will be blocked from commenting. Comments on The Stream are hosted by Disqus, with logins available through Disqus, Facebook, Twitter or G+ accounts. You must log in to comment. Please flag any comments you see breaking the rules. More detail is available here.
  • NeverMueller

    Pray for and shun them.

    • jgmusgrove

      Shunning them provides no value; showing them God’s love through yourself might be better.

      • NeverMueller

        Sure it does. When you can not have a relationship with someone you wish to it forces you to consider the reason why.

        • Andrew Mason

          But the conclusion they reach may not be the conclusion you intend. In the case given it’d show that the Christian sister is unwilling to associate with anyone she considers a sinner and sever the relationship.

          • NeverMueller

            well are we not all to separate ourselves from non believers?

      • Jacob Miller

        >> Shunning them provides no value

        I don’t know “NeverMueller” and he might be a lovely guy. But his reactionary screen name makes me wonder if a little distance would be of value for the family member.

    • porcupineman1454

      No. That’s the worst possible advice you could give short of “DON’T pray for them and do shun them.”

      • NeverMueller

        2 Thessalonians 3:14)

        • Andrew Mason

          That applies to believing brethren who refuse to obey God, yet this case pertains to a sister who may have walked away from her faith. Verse 15 of that chapter says not to regard the person as an enemy but warn them as a brother. Someone who walks away doesn’t need warning – is no longer a ‘brother’ but needs support.

          • NeverMueller

            We will have to disagree on this point.

  • Jacob Miller

    Also, avoid labeling them as “apostate.”

    Not that the word is wrong but nobody likes to be labeled.

    Besides, they probably didn’t just leave Christianity, they probably changed to something else. It’s sort of like the term “non-Christian.” “Apostate” and “non-Christian” are generalists labels that don’t enlighten you on who your loved-one is right now.

    PS: I’m not critical of the article. I especially like the relationship and listening parts.

    • apostate means someone who has rejected God outright. They did “change to something else,” they changed into reprobate’s courting damnation.

Is Your Heart Heavy? God Knew It Would Be
Charles Spurgeon
More from The Stream
Connect with Us